Overall crashworthiness evaluations

Midsize luxury/near luxury cars

current models | earlier models

 

Good Good Acceptable Acceptable Marginal Marginal Poor Poor

Vehicles are listed in order of performance in crash tests. Frontal crash test ratings can be compared only among vehicles of similar weight; side impact crash test ratings can be compared across vehicle type and weight categories.


2009 Top Safety Pick Acura TSX 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
2009 Top Safety Pick Acura TL 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
2009 Top Safety Pick Audi A4 2009 models with standard but without additional optional side airbags
ESC
standard
2009 Top Safety Pick Saab 9-3 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
2009 Top Safety Pick Mercedes C class 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
2009 Top Safety Pick BMW 3 series 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
2009 Top Safety Pick Lincoln MKZ 2010 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
Lexus IS 250/350 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
Lexus ES 350 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
Infiniti G35/G37 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
Volvo S60 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard
Saab 9-5 2009 models with standard side airbags
ESC
standard

Notes:

  1. This rating is assigned by the Institute based on a test conducted by the manufacturer as part of frontal crash test verification.
  2. Two tests of this vehicle were conducted, one by the Institute and the other by the vehicle manufacturer as part of frontal crash test verification. Ratings are based on both tests.
  3. This rating is assigned by the Institute based on a test conducted by the manufacturer as part of side crash test verification.

Additional information:
How tests are conducted and how the Institute determines ratings
Frontal technical measurements for midsize luxury/near luxury cars
Side impact technical measurements for midsize luxury/near luxury cars

©1996-2009, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Highway Loss Data Institute
1005 N. Glebe Road, Suite 800, Arlington, VA 22201 USA | tel 703/247-1500 | fax 703/247-1588