HIGHWAY SAFETY RESEARCH & COMMUNICATIONS

Bumper evaluations

Midsize moderately priced cars

Select another class:
current models | include earlier designs

The Institute's series of 4 tests (front and rear full-width impacts at 6 mph and front and rear corner impacts at 3 mph) produce the kinds and amounts of damage that commonly occur in low-speed collisions. Each vehicle is run into a steel barrier designed to mimic the design of a car bumper, with the barrier's plastic absorber and flexible cover simulating typical cars' energy absorbers and plastic bumper covers. These tests are designed to drive bumper improvements that lead to better protection from damage in a range of real-world crashes.

How the overall rating is determined: The front full and rear full test damages are multiplied by two — because in the real world full- width impacts occur approximately twice as often as corner impacts — and that total is added to the front corner and rear corner test damages. The sum is then divided by six to get the weighted average. This number determines the overall rating. The good/acceptable boundary is $500, the acceptable/marginal boundary is $1,000 and the marginal/poor boundary is $1,500. However, no vehicle can earn a rating of good or acceptable if it is deemed undrivable or unsafe after a test because of headlamp or taillamp damage, hood buckling, coolant loss or the like. For further information, see our bumper test protocols.

Good Good   Acceptable Acceptable   Marginal Marginal   Poor Poor   |   Vehicles are listed in order of performance


Front full bumper test
Front full
test damage
Front corner bumper test
Front corner
test damage
Rear full bumper test
Rear full
test damage
Rear corner bumper test
Rear corner
test damage
Overall weighted
average damage
Overall rating
Kia Optima
2006 - 2010
$1,794 $1,576 $1,729 $811 $1,572 Poor
Volkswagen Passat
2006 - 2010
$5,252 $1,783 $1,149 $1,333 $2,653 Poor
Chevrolet Malibu
2006 - 2007
$1,268 $1,610 $2,542 $1,226 $1,743 Poor
Chrysler Sebring
2007 - 2010
$1,393 $2,484 $3,329 $1,346 $2,212 Poor
Ford Fusion
2007 - 2009
$1,620 $991 $1,298 $1,121 $1,325 Marginal
Honda Accord
2006 - 2007
$3,469 $1,169 $2,763 $605 $2,373 Poor
Hyundai Sonata
2006 - 2008
$4,312 $1,349 $739 $1,165 $2,102 Poor
Mazda 6
2006 - 2008
$978 $1,384 $1,202 $1,397 $1,190 Marginal
Mitsubishi Galant
2006 - 2012
$969 $1,109 $990 $1,185 $1,035 Marginal
Nissan Altima
2007 - 2010
$922 $1,090 $3,309 $1,567 $1,853 Poor
Nissan Maxima
2006 - 2008
$4,535 $1,732 $1,787 $997 $2,562 Poor
Pontiac G6
2006 - 2010
$5,301 $1,361 $1,913 $1,801 $2,932 Poor
Saturn AURA
2007 - 2009
$1,201 $1,235 $3,556 $1,091 $1,973 Poor
Subaru Legacy
2006 - 2009
$4,049 $1,275 $1,169 $1,233 $2,157 Poor
Toyota Camry
2007 - 2010
$1,041 $1,670 $1,612 $1,127 $1,350 Marginal
Volkswagen Jetta
2006 - 2011
$3,033 $1,525 $3,992 $1,959 $2,922 Poor
Volvo S40
2006 - 2012
$2,776 $1,446 $1,065 $1,335 $1,744 Poor
Chevrolet Malibu
2008 - 2012
$2,092 $1,685 $3,494 $1,116 $2,329 Poor
Honda Accord
2008 - 2012
$941 $1,461 $974 $1,507 $1,133 Marginal
Hyundai Sonata
2009 - 2010
$1,791 $1,019 $1,131 $729 $1,265 Marginal
Mazda 6
2009 - 2012
$742 $1,437 $768 $767 $871 Acceptable
Nissan Maxima
2009 - 2012
$997 $1,787 $2,494 $1,352 $1,687 Poor
Ford Fusion
2010 - 2012
$2,529 $1,889 $2,610 $1,073 $2,207 Poor
Subaru Legacy
2010 - 2012
$847 $850 $903 $778 $855 Acceptable

©1996-2013, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Highway Loss Data Institute
1005 N. Glebe Road, Suite 800, Arlington, VA 22201 USA | tel 703/247-1500 | fax 703/247-1588